
After months of delays and some resistance, on 17 June 2024, the EU’s landmark Nature Restoration Law received its final approval from environment ministers in the Council of the EU. Almost 9% of Irish land is expected to be directly affected by the EU Nature Restoration Law. This Just the Facts explains why the Law’s adoption was delayed, what it aims to achieve, and what its practical implementation might look like in Ireland.
Adoption of the EU Nature Restoration Law
Half of the world’s GDP is moderately or highly dependent on nature. However, according to an assessment published by the European Environmental Agency’s (EEA) in 2023, Europe’s biodiversity continues to decline at an alarming rate, with most protected species and habitats found to have a poor conservation status. According to Ireland’s Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), 85% of the 59 Irish habitats listed under the EU Habitats Directive, covering marine, freshwater, peatland, grassland and woodland habitats, were reported as having “unfavourable status”. Agriculture, the extraction of resources (including peat), as well as urbanisation and invasive species, were all cited as being the main pressures.
In this context of alarming rates of nature degradation, on 27 March 2024, the European Parliament adopted the EU Nature Restoration Law (NRL), with 329 votes in favour, 275 against and 24 abstentions. 11 of Ireland’s 13 MEPs voted to support the NRL.
On 17 June 2024, the NRL received its final approval from the EU’s environment ministers in the Council of the EU. Under the qualified majority voting system in the Council, the Law needed the support of at least 15 Member States representing 65% or more of the EU population. Six countries voted against the NRL, including Italy, Hungary, Finland, Sweden, the Netherlands, and Poland. One country – Belgium – abstained. The remaining 20 Member States, including Ireland voted to adopt the Law.
In a preliminary vote among EU Member States’ ambassadors on 22 March 2024, a last-minute rejection from Hungary, who was previously believed to be in favour of the NRL, saw the Law rejected. This rejection came at a time when farmers across the EU were protesting rising costs, reduced incomes and the burdens associated with overregulation. Ultimately, it was Austria’s shift in position that proved to be crucial to meet the threshold needed for a qualified majority. Austria voted against the NRL, in March’s preliminary vote; however, in the final June vote, Austria’s environment minister, who is a member of the Austrian Greens, voted in favour of the NRL, contrary to the position of the conservative-led Austrian government.
Objectives
While EU environmental policies have in the past focused on protecting nature, the NRL aims to address nature sites that have already been degraded and restore them back to a healthy condition. This new regulation legally binds EU Member States to restore at least 20% of the EU’s land and sea areas by 2030 and all ecosystems in need of restoration by 2050. The proposed target builds on the international commitment and obligations of the EU and its Member States as a parties to the global Convention on Biological Diversity.
Regarding specific habitats covered by the new Law, Member States are required to restore 30% of habitats, including forests, grasslands, wetlands, rivers, lakes and coral beds from poor to good condition by 2030. This target will increase to 60% of those habitats by 2040, and 90% by 2050.
The NRL specifically addresses pollinators, enshrining new rules that aim to reverse pollinator decline and increase populations by 2030. Moreover, the Law includes provisions on the protection of species associated with agricultural ecosystems such as grassland butterflies and farmland birds. Under the regulation, Member States are required to enhance the carbon stock in mineral soils and increase high-diversity landscape features on agricultural land (such as hedgerows, flower strips, fallow land, ponds and fruit trees). Regarding forestation, the NRL tasks Member States with increasing the amount of tree cover in urban spaces and contributing to the planting of at least three billion trees by 2030 at the EU level.
Implementation
The Council has stated that examples of restoration measures could include removing non-native plants on grasslands, wetlands and in forests; rewetting drained peatlands; improving connectivity between habitats; stopping or reducing the use of chemical pesticides and fertilisers; and promoting wilderness preservation.
In a letter sent to MEP Billy Kelleher in March 2024, European Commissioner for the Environment, Oceans and Fisheries, Virginijus Sinkevičius, responded to questions on the Nature Restoration Law. The Commissioner’s answers mentioned that the implementation of the NRL is in the hands of the Irish Government and that there is considerable flexibility being afforded to Member States. It is the state – not individuals – who is bound by the obligations set out in the NRL. While the government will seek to incentivize landowner participation in all restoration measures, this will be on a strictly voluntary basis, including the rewetting of peatlands. Ireland’s Minister of State for Heritage Malcolm Noonan has also made clear that Ireland’s 2030 and 2040 targets for rewetting bogs could be achieved by concentrating on State-owned lands. Additionally, Commissioner Sinkevičius confirmed that the measures will also not have any negative impacts on any Common Agricultural Policy (CAP) commitments or payments.
The NRL is envisaged to come under existing EU funding streams such as the LIFE Programme, the European Agricultural Fund for Rural Development (EAFRD) and the European Agricultural Guarantee Fund (EAGF). The Irish Government has set aside a €3.15bn Climate and Nature Fund, which was announced as part of Budget 2024, to support the implementation of nature restoration measures across the country.
Next Steps
The regulation will now be published in the EU’s Official Journal and enter into force. As soon as it is published, it will become directly applicable in all Member States. EU countries are expected to submit National Restoration Plans to the Commission within two years of the Regulation coming into force (so by mid-2026), showing how they will deliver on the targets. They will also be required to monitor and report on their progress. By 2033, the Commission will review the application of the regulation and its impacts on the agricultural, fisheries and forestry sectors, as well as its wider socio-economic effects.
The European Environment Agency (EEA) will draw up regular technical reports on progress towards the targets. The Commission, in turn, will report to the European Parliament and to the Council on the implementation of the Nature Restoration Law.
In Ireland, work has already started on a participatory stakeholder engagement process to support the development of the Ireland’s National Restoration Plan over the next 24 months. Led by an independent Chair, this programme will comprise a series of interactive workshops aligned with key themes focussing on the impact of the regulation on land, marine and urban environments. Stakeholders, including farmers and farming representatives, will be encouraged to get involved.
Most recent EMI Publications:
Subscribe now to The EU Inside Track!
Welcome to The EU Inside Track, a new briefing update from EM Ireland. We aim to bring you key developments from Brussels, Strasbourg and beyond in an accessible, digestible format. You can subscribe now for timely updates straight to your email inbox.
